Kathryn
I love and totally trust life. Life LOVES life!. Learning to work with, and trust, nature is the path forward - we will discover what we need to know as we walk. Archives
September 2026
Categories
All
|
Back to Blog
Being kind is not enough.
Kindness is supposed to be the foundation of a convivial relationship — a sign that we care about each other. But I want you to think about the flip side of kindness: withholding. Because withholding, not generosity, is the actual foundation of much of our society. And it comes from a single belief, repeated in a hundred disguises: there is not enough. We are not enough. Both are illusions. But they run deep, and they show up simultaneously in three places — in ourselves, in each other, and in our relationship with the earth. Withholding from Ourselves We withhold energy from the things we love and pour it instead into the things that earn status, or that someone else asked of us, or that we feel we should want. A parent who spends Sunday catching up on emails instead of finishing the painting they've been dreaming about for months is withholding from themselves — trading the thing with real energy in it for the thing that looks responsible. I learned something about this early, running a home cleaning business: cleaning and maintenance are acts of love. Bathing a baby, feeding that small mouth — nobody calls that a chore. We call it care. Withhold it, and we call it cruelty. So why does the equation change the moment we become adults, or the moment love turns into infrastructure? As a society, we pour money into building new things and starve the maintenance budget for what we already have — the bridge that needs inspecting, the water main that's been due for replacement for a decade, the relationship that just needs someone to show up. Construction gets the ribbon-cutting. Maintenance gets ignored until it fails. That's withholding, dressed up as budgeting. Withholding from Each Other We also withhold attention — and we're very good at justifying it. It's not my business. I can't do anything about it anyway. It would be too painful to look at. All illusions. Here's the thing about attention: what gets attention grows. We already half-know this — "what you measure is what happens" — but we apply it selectively. Watch what most of us actually pay attention to in other people: how they're different, how they do things wrong, how their beliefs or habits are annoying or backward. We rehearse the friction. And the friction grows, because we fed it. Now imagine turning that same attention toward delight instead. A coworker's odd, meticulous way of organizing a spreadsheet — instead of finding it fussy, find it fascinating. A neighbor's very different politics — instead of cataloguing the ways they're wrong, get curious about how they arrived there, and what in their life makes sense of it. That, too, would grow, the same way friction grows, just by being fed. We want to be kind, but we forget how to actually care — and caring requires action, not just goodwill. We have excellent reasons for not acting: we're short on time, it's not our place, we're afraid of embarrassing them or ourselves. So the good intention stays inside us, invisible, and the only thing anyone else can see is the withholding. We then get read as people who don't care — because from the outside, unexpressed care and absent care look identical. So notice it. Notice the moment you see someone struggling in the checkout line and talk yourself out of a small kindness. Notice the thing on the side of the road that caught your attention and that you drove past anyway. Ask what you could hold instead of withhold — their kindness, their difference, their curious path to being who they are. Practice offering something small, gently, maybe with humor, held loosely enough that it doesn't matter how it lands. It only matters that you offered it. Withholding from the Earth The pattern repeats at planetary scale. We even withhold our own bodies at death — sealed in steel and concrete vaults, when every other living thing returns its body to feed what comes next. What's the point of a coffin liner rated to resist the earth for a hundred years? We're withholding ourselves from the cycle we depend on, right down to the last transaction we could make with it. Nearly everyone has some piece of land they touch — a yard, a windowsill, a community garden bed, even a single planter on an apartment balcony. The question is whether we're caring for it or just decorating with it. Fertilizer, herbicide, and lawn chemicals are usually applied for us — for a green lawn that photographs well, not because the soil asked for nutrition. That's extraction wearing gardening gloves. It takes life and nutrition from the ground and gives back very little. We love nature in the abstract. We hike it, we photograph it, we donate to it. But loving nature and tending nature are different actions with different consequences. We rarely show up at the zoning meeting or the utility hearing where the actual decisions about a watershed or a wetland get made. Not my business. Too small to matter. Same illusions, same excuses, just aimed at the planet instead of a person. And when we build, we tell ourselves that leaving a few trees standing counts as care. It doesn't — it just reduces the damage. A subdivision that ignores how water already wants to move across that land will flood. A building that ignores the local wind and sun will run hot or cold and blame the weather for it. But it isn't the earth's fault. It's ours — we didn't ask what the land wanted before we withheld our attention and built anyway. Holding Instead of Withholding Kindness toward ourselves, toward each other, toward the ground under our feet — it's the same discipline, practiced at three different scales. And maybe, if we can relearn it before the hot times now arriving, the earth can still teach us how to survive them.
0 Comments
Read More
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
RSS Feed